Skip to content
ilustreando.com

Home / Blog / Sketchbook comparison: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm vs Stillman & Birn vs Hahnemühle

Sketchbook comparison: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm vs Stillman & Birn vs Hahnemühle

Sketchbook comparison: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm vs Stillman & Birn vs Hahnemühle

In this sketchbook comparison the short answer is: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm look very similar on the outside, but the Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook has slightly heavier paper (180 gsm versus 165 gsm) and numbered pages; Stillman & Birn is the best choice if you paint with water, especially the 270 gsm Beta; and Hahnemühle wins for graphite, charcoal and ink thanks to the smooth 190 gsm paper in the Nostalgie. If you only draw in pencil or ink, any of the four will do; if you use watercolour or markers, the brand really matters.

We are not repeating the general list of sketchbooks or the theory of paper here. For that, see our guide to the best sketchbooks for drawing and our explanation of paper types for illustration. This guide focuses on what changes from one brand to another.

In short

  • Moleskine Art Sketchbook: 165 gsm ivory paper, ideal to carry around and draw in pencil and ink.
  • Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook: 180 gsm, acid-free, lies completely flat and has numbered pages.
  • Stillman & Birn Beta: 270 gsm with a medium grain, the best prepared for watercolour and gouache.
  • Stillman & Birn Alpha: versatile white paper for graphite, ink, markers and light washes.
  • Hahnemühle Nostalgie: very smooth 190 gsm paper, the favourite for graphite, charcoal and ink.

Sketchbook comparison table: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm vs Stillman & Birn vs Hahnemühle

Model Paper weight Surface Binding Pencil and ink Markers Watercolour Indicative price
Moleskine Art Sketchbook 165 gsm Smooth, ivory Hardcover, sewn, lies flat Very good Good with light layers Very light washes only Approx. €20 to €35
Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook 180 gsm Smooth, acid-free Hardcover, lies completely flat Very good Good Light washes Approx. €20 to €35
Stillman & Birn Alpha Medium weight White, lightly textured Hardcover or spiral depending on version Very good Very good Light washes Approx. €20 to €40
Stillman & Birn Beta 270 gsm Medium grain Hardcover or spiral depending on version Good Good Very good, several layers Approx. €25 to €45
Hahnemühle Nostalgie 190 gsm Very smooth Sewn Excellent Good Not recommended Approx. €15 to €30

Prices are indicative, depend heavily on size and change often. Use them to place each brand, not as an exact price.

Compare these 4 products side by side

Moleskine vs Leuchtturm: the two everyday sketchbooks

These are the two easiest sketchbooks to find and the ones people compare most. Both have hard covers, come in pocket or medium sizes and have a sober look that fits as well in a backpack as in a meeting. The difference lies in the paper and the details.

Moleskine Art Sketchbook

The Moleskine Art Sketchbook uses 165 gsm ivory paper, with a hard cover, elastic closure and inner pocket. The ivory tone softens the contrast and looks great with black ink and pencil. Its smooth surface lets a fineliner glide without catching, and it pairs well with a Sakura Pigma Micron or a brush pen.

Its weak point shows when you load the paper heavily. With alcohol markers you may see some show-through on the next page, and with a lot of water the paper tends to buckle. If you want to paint with watercolour within the Moleskine family, the brand has a dedicated notebook for it, which we cover below.

Classic Moleskine Art Sketchbook

Moleskine Art Sketchbook

The quintessential pocket sketchbook, with thick ivory paper.

  • 165 gsm paper
  • Hard cover with elastic closure
  • Inner pocket

€ 28.00Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Moleskine Art Sketchbook

Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook

The Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook goes up to 180 gsm with acid-free paper, lies completely flat and has numbered pages. Those 15 extra grams do not turn it into a watercolour book, but you notice them with markers or light washes: the paper holds up a little better and the page behind suffers less. Lying completely flat is a real advantage if you like working across a double spread or scanning your drawings.

Page numbering seems like a minor detail, but it is useful if you keep your sketchbook as a visual diary and want to find a specific study months later. It is also sold in several cover colours, which helps if you carry more than one sketchbook at a time.

Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook

Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook

180 gsm paper suitable for mixed media, with numbered pages.

  • Lies completely flat
  • Acid-free paper
  • Several cover colours

€ 24.95Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook

Verdict: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm

If you mainly draw in pencil and ink and like the warm tone of the paper, the Moleskine is a classic that never fails. If you mix techniques, use markers often or work across double spreads, the Leuchtturm1917 is the most balanced buy thanks to its heavier paper and fully flat opening.

Stillman & Birn: the brand for painting in your sketchbook

Stillman & Birn is the brand many illustrators choose when their sketchbook can no longer cope with water. Instead of a single paper, it offers several series named after Greek letters, each with a different weight and surface. Our catalogue includes the two most useful ones to start with: Alpha and Beta.

Stillman & Birn Alpha

The Stillman & Birn Alpha has medium-weight white paper that is very versatile. It works with graphite, ink, markers and light washes, and the pure white lets colours look exactly as they are, something the ivory of the Moleskine cannot do. It is the choice for anyone who wants an all-round sketchbook with studio quality, without painting with a lot of water.

Stillman & Birn Alpha

Stillman & Birn Alpha

Very versatile medium-weight white paper: graphite, ink, markers and light washes.

  • Very versatile paper
  • Takes light washes
  • Studio quality

€ 31.03Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Stillman & Birn Alpha

Stillman & Birn Beta

The Stillman & Birn Beta is in another league: 270 gsm with a medium grain, designed for watercolour and gouache. It takes several layers and buckles far less than any of the everyday sketchbooks in this comparison. The medium grain adds texture to washes, although it makes fineliner lines slightly less crisp than on smooth paper. If your sketchbook is for colour studies, this is the one that will give you the most.

For watercolour Stillman & Birn Beta

Stillman & Birn Beta

A sketchbook designed for painting with watercolour and gouache without the paper buckling.

  • 270 gsm paper
  • Medium grain
  • Handles several layers

€ 28.60Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Stillman & Birn Beta

To complete your painting kit, check our guide to watercolour supplies for beginners.

Hahnemühle: smooth paper for graphite and ink

Hahnemühle is a paper maker with a long tradition, and you can feel it. Its sketchbooks are designed more for drawing than for painting.

Hahnemühle Nostalgie

The Hahnemühle Nostalgie has very soft 190 gsm paper, a smooth surface and a sewn binding. It is the paper in this comparison that responds best to graphite and charcoal: it allows smooth gradients, stands up to a kneaded eraser and lets a fineliner glide without snagging. Its weight is higher than Moleskine and Leuchtturm, but such a smooth surface is not designed to hold water, so it is not the best choice for watercolour.

Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook

If you want to move away from white paper, the Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook comes with grey or beige toned paper. The idea is to build shadows with graphite or ink and highlights with a white pencil, something you cannot do in a white sketchbook. It is a very interesting alternative for volume and portrait studies.

Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook

Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook

Grey or beige toned paper for adding highlights with white pencil and shadows with graphite or ink.

  • Toned paper
  • Ideal for light and shadow
  • Sewn binding

€ 15.18Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook

What if I want watercolour in a Moleskine format?

The Moleskine Cuaderno de Acuarela is the brand’s answer for those who want to paint without giving up its format. It has watercolour-ready paper, a landscape format and a sturdy hard cover. The landscape format is very practical for landscapes and travel journals. Compared with the Stillman & Birn Beta, you gain a very comfortable format for panoramas; the Beta, in return, offers more sizes and paper that takes many layers.

For watercolour Moleskine Watercolour Notebook

Moleskine Watercolour Notebook

Landscape format with thick watercolour paper, perfect for travel journals and colour sketches.

  • Watercolour-friendly paper
  • Landscape format
  • Sturdy hard cover

€ 29.00Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm

Learn more for Moleskine Watercolour Notebook

How to choose between Moleskine, Leuchtturm, Stillman & Birn and Hahnemühle

  1. Start with your technique. Pencil and ink: any of them works, with the Hahnemühle Nostalgie as the most pleasant. Markers: Leuchtturm1917 or Stillman & Birn Alpha. Watercolour: Stillman & Birn Beta or the Moleskine watercolour notebook.
  2. Look at paper weight, but not only the number. 165, 180 and 190 gsm are drawing papers; 270 gsm is already painting paper. Surface matters as much as weight: a smooth 190 gsm paper handles water worse than one with grain.
  3. Decide whether it needs to lie flat. For double spreads and scanning, the Leuchtturm1917 is the most comfortable. If you never want to fight the spine, the spiral versions of Stillman & Birn are another option.
  4. Choose the paper colour. Ivory (Moleskine) for a warm feel; white (Stillman & Birn) to see colours as they are; toned (Hahnemühle Toned) to work highlights.
  5. Think about size. A pocket sketchbook gets used more because it is always with you. A large one gives more room but weighs more. Many illustrators combine a small one for everyday use and a larger one for studies.

If you will work mostly in colour, our guide to the best markers for illustration helps you pair sketchbook and marker.

Conclusion

In this sketchbook comparison there is no brand that is best at everything, only one that is best for each technique. Moleskine is the classic pocket sketchbook for pencil and ink. Leuchtturm1917 is the most balanced for everyday use and gentle mixed media. Stillman & Birn is the go-to brand if you paint in your sketchbook, with the Alpha as the all-rounder and the Beta for watercolour. Hahnemühle offers the most pleasant paper for graphite, charcoal and ink. You can see every model in the sketchbooks and notebooks category.

Compare these 3 products side by side

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for drawing, Moleskine or Leuchtturm1917?

For drawing, the Leuchtturm1917 Sketchbook is usually a little more versatile because its paper is 180 gsm compared with the 165 gsm of the Moleskine Art Sketchbook, and it lies completely flat. The Moleskine stands out for its ivory paper and classic pocket format.

Which sketchbook handles watercolour best?

In this comparison, the Stillman & Birn Beta, with 270 gsm and a medium grain, handles several layers of watercolour and gouache best. The Moleskine Cuaderno de Acuarela is another good option if you prefer a landscape format.

Can I use alcohol markers in a Moleskine?

Yes, but carefully. With a lot of ink you may see some show-through on the next page. If you use markers often, heavier paper such as the Leuchtturm1917 or the Stillman & Birn Alpha gives better results. A protective sheet behind the page also helps.

What is the Hahnemühle Nostalgie for?

It is designed for graphite, charcoal and ink. Its 190 gsm paper is very smooth and allows soft gradients and clean lines, but it is not the most suitable for watercolour.

How much does a good sketchbook cost?

As an indicative reference, the models in this comparison usually range from about €15 to €45 depending on brand and size. Prices change often, so compare them when you buy.

Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Ilustreando earns a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *