In the Polychromos vs Prismacolor comparison (plus Neocolor II) there is no single winner, because these are three different tools: Faber-Castell Polychromos are oil-based pencils, firm and precise, ideal for thin layers and detail; Prismacolor Premier are wax-based pencils, soft and creamy, that blend and saturate very quickly; and Caran d’Ache Neocolor II are water-soluble wax pastels, not pencils, designed for backgrounds, textures and mixed media with water. If you want the best coloured pencils for illustration in a single set, Polychromos is the most balanced choice; if you want intense colour and smooth blends with little effort, go for Prismacolor; and if you work with large areas of colour or mix with watercolour, choose Neocolor II.
Below you will see how they perform in pigment, hardness, layering, blending, breakage, lightfastness and paper, and which one suits the way you draw.
In short
- Faber-Castell Polychromos: oil-based, harder core, the point lasts, many layers and good lightfastness. The most versatile option.
- Prismacolor Premier: wax-based, very soft core, blends and covers easily, but breaks more often and wears down fast.
- Caran d’Ache Neocolor II: highly opaque water-soluble wax pastels, used dry or with water. Perfect for backgrounds and textures, not for fine detail.
- Many illustrators combine two: Neocolor II for the base and Polychromos for the detail on top.
- Paper matters as much as the pencil: with the right tooth and weight you can build many more layers.
Polychromos vs Prismacolor vs Neocolor II: comparison table
| Aspect | Faber-Castell Polychromos | Prismacolor Premier | Caran d’Ache Neocolor II |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Oil-based coloured pencil | Wax-based coloured pencil | Water-soluble wax pastel |
| Hardness | Medium-firm | Very soft | Soft and thick |
| Pigmentation | High | High | Very high and opaque |
| Layering | Many thin, controlled layers | Few before the paper saturates | Thick layers or washes with water |
| Blending | Gradual, by layering | Very easy and creamy | With fingers, a blending stump or water |
| Fine detail | Excellent, holds its point | Fair, the point wears quickly | Limited |
| Breakage | Rare | More common if the pencil is knocked | Sturdy, but wear down fast |
| Wax bloom | Almost none | Can appear in dense layers | Can appear when used dry |
| Use with water | No | No | Yes, they dissolve like watercolour |
| Indicative price | Mid-high | Mid | Mid |
Compare these 3 products side by side
Prices change often and depend on the size of the set, so treat the last row only as an indicative reference between brands.
Faber-Castell Polychromos: precision and layering
Polychromos are oil-based coloured pencils. This means the binder in the core includes oils rather than relying mainly on wax. In practice you get a firmer core that sharpens well, keeps its point for longer and leaves a clean line.
Their great strength is layering. You can stack many thin glazes, adjust the tone little by little and keep adding colour without the paper saturating as early as it does with a wax core. That is why they are so popular in botanical illustration, realistic portraiture, wildlife and any work that demands control.
Faber-Castell rates the lightfastness of each colour with a star system, and much of the range scores highly. If you are going to sell or exhibit originals, it is worth checking colour by colour.
What to know before buying
- They cost a bit more than other ranges, but they last a long time because the core wears down slowly.
- Blending is slower: do not expect two colours to merge after a couple of strokes.
- They produce hardly any wax bloom, so you can work dense layers without fixative.
Faber-Castell Polychromos
Oil-based coloured pencils with rich pigmentation and lightfastness.
- Intense colours
- Do not break easily
- Ideal for layering
€ 34.94Price as of November 9, 2026 1:10 pm
Learn more for Faber-Castell PolychromosPrismacolor Premier: creamy colour and fast blending
Prismacolor Premier have a very soft wax-based core. With light pressure they lay down a lot of pigment, fill the tooth of the paper and blend almost like a pastel. If you like saturated finishes, smooth gradients and working fast, they are very rewarding.
That same softness has drawbacks. The point wears down quickly and you need to sharpen often, the core is more fragile and tends to break if the pencil is dropped or if you use a blunt sharpener. Also, after several layers the paper fills with wax and stops accepting colour, and in heavily worked areas the so-called wax bloom can appear, a whitish film that you can remove by gently rubbing with a cloth or prevent with a fixative.
Lightfastness varies quite a lot from colour to colour, so if your work will be on display it is wise to avoid the less stable shades or keep originals away from direct light.
Who they are for
For anyone doing vivid colour illustration, fan art, stylised portraits or work where visual impact comes first. They also complement Polychromos well: many artists build layers with oil-based pencil first and finish with Prismacolor to burnish and unify.
Prismacolor Premier (24)
Soft-core coloured pencils that blend and cover very well, for saturated finishes.
- Soft, creamy core
- Blend beautifully
- Intense colours
€ 40.49Price as of November 9, 2026 1:12 pm
Learn more for Prismacolor Premier (24)Caran d’Ache Neocolor II: water-soluble wax pastels for backgrounds and textures
Neocolor II are not coloured pencils but water-soluble wax pastels. They come as thick sticks, are highly opaque and can be used in two ways: dry, like a crayon, or activated with water to get washes similar to watercolour or gouache.
They are ideal for covering large areas quickly, creating backgrounds, rubbing textures and colour bases to work over later with another medium. They also work on toned paper, cardboard or unusual surfaces, which makes them very useful for mixed media and travel sketchbooks.
Their limit is detail: with a stick that thick you will not draw eyelashes or fine textures. The usual approach is to combine them with coloured pencils or markers on top once the wet layer has dried.
Quick tips
- Pick up colour straight from the stick with a wet brush to use them like a watercolour palette.
- If you plan to wet them a lot, use heavy paper so it does not buckle.
- When dry, scrape the layer with a blade to reveal textures (sgraffito).
Caran d’Ache Neocolor II
Water-soluble wax pastels used dry or with water, ideal for textures and quick backgrounds.
- Water-soluble
- Highly opaque
- For mixed media
€ 34.49Price as of November 9, 2026 1:10 pm
Learn more for Caran d’Ache Neocolor IIWhich paper to use with each
Paper completely changes the result. Polychromos perform very well on paper with some tooth that holds pigment and allows many layers. With Prismacolor, smooth paper gives very soft gradients, while paper with a pronounced tooth lets you add more layers before it saturates. For wet Neocolor II you need heavy watercolour or mixed media paper. If in doubt, our guide to types of paper for illustration explains weights and tooth.
To use the pastels with water in a sketchbook, the Stillman & Birn Beta handles several wet layers without warping. And if you like working highlights with a white pencil, the toned paper of the Hahnemühle Toned Sketchbook pairs very well with Polychromos.
Stillman & Birn Beta
A sketchbook designed for painting with watercolour and gouache without the paper buckling.
- 270 gsm paper
- Medium grain
- Handles several layers
€ 28.60Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm
Learn more for Stillman & Birn Beta
Faber-Castell Kneaded Eraser
Eraser you shape with your fingers to lighten areas and lift highlights without damaging the paper.
- Leaves no crumbs
- Lifts highlights precisely
- Lasts a long time
€ 6.56Price as of November 9, 2026 1:11 pm
Learn more for Faber-Castell Kneaded EraserA kneaded eraser is a coloured pencil essential: it will not fully erase an oil or wax core, but it gently lifts pigment to lighten areas and recover highlights without damaging the paper.
How to choose your coloured pencils
- Think about your style. If you want realism, detail and control, start with an oil-based pencil. If you prefer flat, saturated and fast colour, a soft wax core will make life easier.
- Consider how much you will blend. Wax blends in seconds; oil does it by layering. Neither is better, just different.
- Decide whether you want water. If you are interested in mixed media or watercolour-style backgrounds, water-soluble pastels open up options that dry pencils do not.
- Check lightfastness. If you will sell or exhibit originals, look up the rating of each colour.
- Start with a small set. A well-chosen set of 12 or 24 colours teaches you more than 120 unused shades. Add open stock later. Reviewing colour theory for illustrators will help you get more out of a short palette.
If you are putting your kit together from scratch, also check our checklist of basic drawing supplies to get started.
Conclusion: Polychromos or Prismacolor?
If you are only buying one set and want it to cover almost everything, choose Polychromos: they are precise, handle many layers, rarely break and their lightfastness is well documented. If you are drawn to juicy colour and fast blends and do not mind sharpening often, Prismacolor Premier will give you eye-catching results with little effort. And if you want backgrounds, textures or to combine with water, add some Neocolor II, which work very well alongside either. You can find more options in our drawing supplies section.
Compare these 4 products side by side
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between oil-based and wax-based coloured pencils?
Oil-based pencils, like Polychromos, have a firmer core, keep their point and allow many thin layers. Wax-based pencils, like Prismacolor Premier, are softer, cover and blend faster, but saturate the paper sooner and can produce wax bloom.
Can you mix Polychromos and Prismacolor in the same drawing?
Yes, and it is a very common combination. The usual approach is to build the first layers with Polychromos and finish with Prismacolor to burnish and unify, because wax over oil behaves better than the other way round.
Are Neocolor II watercolour pencils?
Not exactly. They are water-soluble wax pastels in a thick stick. They dissolve with water like a watercolour pencil, but they cover much more and are not suited to fine detail.
Why do Prismacolor cores break so often?
Because the core is very soft. Knocks and drops can fracture it inside the wood, and a blunt sharpener can snap it as you turn. Store them carefully and use a good quality sharpener.
What are the best coloured pencils to start with in illustration?
A small set of Polychromos is a safe investment that will last you years. If your budget is tight, start with a few colours and expand with open stock as you use them up.
Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Ilustreando earns a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Leave a Reply